Gumshoe vs Zumi | AI Visibility Platform Comparison
Gumshoe vs Zumi
Both platforms track brand visibility and citations in AI search. Gumshoe runs more models and buyer personas at the same entry price, and drafts the content to close the gaps.
Overview
gumshoe.ai is used by 10,000+ brands and agencies. It has generated 60,000+ reports, analyzed 185,000+ personas and measured 4.5M+ brands. Each audit runs structured conversations as defined buyer personas, then shows which brands AI models mention, how often, for whom, and which sources they cite.
Zumi describes itself as AI search intelligence for brand strategy, built for marketing leaders, in-house brand teams and agencies. Its two pillars are AI visibility and citations. This page compares the two using Zumi's public pricing and product pages.
Gumshoe vs Zumi: Feature Comparison
| Capability | Gumshoe | Zumi |
|---|---|---|
| Data collection method | Official model APIs, no chat-interface automation | Not documented |
| AI models at $99/mo | 6 per audit, drawn from 12 tracked (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, DeepSeek, Grok, Meta Muse Spark) | ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews |
| Prompt approach | Buyer personas with roles, goals, pain points and decision context; 8 personas and 480+ conversations per Visibility Audit | Buyer questions grouped by category, competitors and topics; 50 prompts on Starter, 100 on Growth |
| Persona analysis | AI-inferred buyer personas; custom and imported personas supported | Not documented |
| Citation source tracking | Domains and URLs AI cites, and every cited page is fetched and read to check whether your brand is named on it | Cited pages and domains |
| Page-level audit | Technical Audit of a page's AI readiness with specific fixes: 10 runs on Build your own, 50 on the Playbook | Citability audit: 1 a month on Starter, 4 on Growth |
| Content generation | Drafts written for you, targeted at the persona and topic gaps an audit finds | Ranked recommendations; drafting not documented |
| Sentiment | Sentiment Audit, included in the Playbook or $100/mo on Build your own | Not documented |
| Pricing model | Free sample audit; Build your own from $99/mo (audits $100/mo each), the Playbook $299/mo; no annual contracts | Starter $99/mo, Growth $399/mo, Enterprise custom |
| Free trial | First audit free, no card required | No trial documented; demo available |
Where gumshoe.ai has clear advantages
More models for the same entry price
Both platforms start at $99. On Zumi's Starter plan, its pricing table lists ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews and 50 tracked prompts. gumshoe.ai's Build your own plan, at $99/mo, runs a monthly Visibility Audit across 6 models you choose from 12, with 8 personas and 480+ conversations, plus weekly Snapshot Audits and 10 Technical Audit runs.
Personas, not only topics
Zumi groups buyer questions by category, competitors and topics. gumshoe.ai adds the buyer. Each audit infers personas with a role, goals, pain points and decision context, then runs conversations as each of them, so a team can see which buyer types AI recommends it to and which it misses.
Content written, not only recommended
Zumi identifies content gaps and ranks what to create. gumshoe.ai also writes it: FAQs, knowledge articles, how-tos, comparisons, social posts and video outlines, each targeted at a persona and topic where the audit found the brand weakest.
Sentiment alongside visibility
gumshoe.ai's Sentiment Audit uses prompts designed to draw out how AI models really describe a brand, including head-to-head comparisons. It is included in the Playbook ($299/mo) or available for $100/mo on Build your own.
Where Zumi has strengths
Product-level tracking
Zumi tracks visibility for individual products without needing a catalog. Retail brands that mainly care which SKU AI recommends may find that level of detail useful.
When to choose each platform
Choose gumshoe.ai when:
- You want several AI models in every audit at the entry price
- You need visibility broken down by buyer persona and topic
- You want gap-targeted content drafted for you, not only recommended
- You want sentiment and page-level audits in the same workflow
- You want to start with a free audit before paying anything
Choose Zumi when:
- Your main question is which individual product or SKU AI recommends
Conclusion
gumshoe.ai fits teams that want to know which buyers see their brand and why, across 6 models from the first paid plan. Persona-driven audits, reproducible API-based runs, page-level Technical Audits, sentiment and drafted content come together in one workflow, with a free first audit and plans from $99/mo.
Zumi is worth a look for retail brands whose main question is which individual product AI recommends.
See the Gumshoe difference for yourself
Run your first AI visibility report for free.
Run a free audit
Free to start · No credit card required